Local, organic & fresh!

Eden Valley Creamery was established in 2017, and started selling cheese early 2019.  Currently, we produce five flavors of fresh cheddar-based cheese curds: plain, garlic, horseradish, sour cream and onion, and Buffalo. As well as four varieties of aged cheeses: Gouda, Swiss,  Havarti and Dill Havarti. You can find our products at various stores and restaurants around the Western New York area, and right at our retail location in South Dayton, NY! 

Our Cheeses

We have created four different types of artisan cheeses for your enjoyment. These cheeses will be great to pair with beer or wine, a light snack, or even to cook gourmet recipes with. 

Gouda, Havarti, Dill Havarti, Cheese Curds, and a Young Swiss are the base cheeses that we have produced.  Our cheese curds have 5 flavors: plain, garlic, sour cream & onion, horseradish and Buffalo. 

If you have any suggestions for flavor types you would like to try comment on our Blog or Facebook page! 


For years, the debate between organic and conventional farming has been ongoing. Eden Valley Organic Dairy Farms strive to provide the utmost care for their animals- which is no different than any other dairy farm. 

Our organic farms are certified through the Pennsylvania Certified Organic Cooperative. We sell our organic milk to Upstate Niagara Cooperative, and from there they bottle our milk and take it to stores for you to enjoy.

Our cows are able to roam around the pastures throughout the spring, summer and fall months enjoying the beautiful weather and eating delicious grass. Organic is more than the cows being out on pasture  and not giving the animals any antibiotics. Organic farming aims to reduce pollution, conserve water, reduce soil erosion, as well as increasing soil fertility. Farming without the use of pesticides creates a better environment for nearby animals and people. Organic milk and dairy products are richer in certain nutrients like the omega-3 fatty acids. Omega-3 fatty acids have a lot of health benefits such as: lowering elevated triglycerides, lowers inflammation for asthma, reduces the symptoms of ADHD, and can help protect against Alzheimer's- just to name a few.  

On the farm, we strive to provide the animals with the utmost care and protection. The safety of our animals and employees is our number one priority every day! 

If you would like to learn more about organic and who we are certified through please visit the Pennsylvania Organic Certifies website here below :

Eden Valley Creamery 

edenvalleycreamery@gmail.com               12540 Dredge Road 

(585)738-2651                                South Dayton, New York

Monday – Saturday    10-5

Sunday    Closed

© 2023 by Barista. Proudly created with Wix.com