top of page
Orders placed Wednesday or later will be shipped Monday morning.

Note: We are working hard to ensure your order arrives in a timely manner, and as safely as possible. Due to volatility in shipping, we have increased our options so you may choose the shipping method best suited to your needs. Please know we pack every order with care. Reach out with any questions with your order!
Mafia Cheddar

Buffalo NY, home to the Bills Mafia! Eden Valley Creamery has created a spicy, buffalo wing flavored cheddar with a marbled appearance, in honor of the Mafia- LETS GO BUFFALO!



LIMITED RELEASE! Get yours before they are gone!

Mafia Cheddar is carefully cut by hand into 1/3lb wedges- each wedge is unique!

Mafia Cheddar

    bottom of page